15 First Fictional Book Characters That Stole Our Hearts

Disclaimer: When you buy from links on our site, we may receive a commission at no additional cost to you.  Learn more

In literature, some characters transcend the pages and become our first loves. These fictional crushes ignited a spark within us, teaching us about the magic of romance and the power of a well-written character. Let’s take a trip down memory lane and revisit the first literary heartthrobs who made us believe in the enchantment of love and the enduring impact of a good book.

Mr. Darcy from “Pride and Prejudice” by Jane Austen

mr. darcy
Image Credit DepositPhotos kathysg

Mr. Darcy, with his brooding charm and hidden depths, captured the hearts of many young readers. His transformative journey from proud aristocrat to a man in love made him an irresistible figure in classic literature.

Gilbert Blythe from “Anne of Green Gables” by L.M. Montgomery

woman reading a book
Image Credit_ DepositPhotos choreograph

Gilbert’s wit, kindness, and rivalry-turned-friendship with Anne Shirley warmed our hearts. His enduring love and support for Anne throughout their lives made him the ultimate fictional crush for many.

Sirius Black from the Harry Potter series by J.K. Rowling

harry potter books
Image Credit_ Depositphotos Wirestock

The rebellious, fiercely loyal Sirius Black stole our hearts with his devil-may-care attitude and tragic backstory. His fierce protectiveness for Harry and his complex relationship with the Marauders added depth to this charming rogue.

Westley from “The Princess Bride” by William Goldman

woman reading
Image Credit_ DepositPhotos HayDmitriy

Westley’s unwavering devotion and his epic quest to rescue Buttercup showcased the epitome of true love. His clever wit and dashing feats of heroism made him an unforgettable character.

Laurie from “Little Women” by Louisa May Alcott

man reading
Image Credit_ DepositPhotos IgorVetushko

The boy-next-door charm of Laurie and his deep connection with the March sisters captured the hearts of readers worldwide. His friendship with Jo and the unrequited love story tugged at our heartstrings.

Edward Cullen from the Twilight series by Stephenie Meyer

vampire
Image Credit_ DepositPhotos rdrgraphe

Edward Cullen, the mysterious vampire with a tortured soul, became the ultimate romantic figure for a generation. His eternal love for Bella and his internal struggle between his nature and his feelings endeared him to many fans.

Rhett Butler from “Gone with the Wind” by Margaret Mitchell

woman reading
Image Credit_ DepositPhotos AntonLozovoy

Rhett Butler’s roguish charm and undeniable chemistry with Scarlett O’Hara made him a captivating character. His wit, independence, and his complicated relationship with Scarlett created a timeless love story.

Captain Hook from “Peter Pan” by J.M. Barrie

peter pan
Image Credit_ DepositPhotos fonafona

Captain Hook’s charismatic villainy and his complex rivalry with Peter Pan made him an unexpected crush for some. His suave demeanor and flair for the dramatic added a layer of fascination to this notorious pirate.

Legolas from “The Lord of the Rings” series by J.R.R. Tolkien

woman reading a book looking confused
Image credits Depositphotos nicoletaionescu

Legolas, the elven prince with his graceful archery and ethereal beauty, captured the imaginations of many readers. His loyalty to the Fellowship and his stoic strength added depth to this beloved character.

Jo March from “Little Women” by Louisa May Alcott

man reading a book
Image Credit_ DepositPhotos ArturVerkhovetskiy

Jo March’s fierce independence, intelligence, and unapologetic pursuit of her dreams resonated with readers of all ages. Her fiery spirit and unwavering loyalty to her family made her an enduring literary crush.

Prince Caspian from “The Chronicles of Narnia” series by C.S. Lewis

the chronicles of narnia
Image Credit_ DepositPhotos modera761101

Prince Caspian’s bravery and his role in the Narnian adventures made him a heroic figure for many young readers. His kindness and sense of duty added to his appeal as a fictional crush.

Gilbert Markham from “The Tenant of Wildfell Hall” by Anne Brontë

woman reading
Image Credit_ DepositPhotos GaudiLab

Gilbert Markham’s steadfast love and determination to win over Helen Graham’s heart in the face of adversity showcased his admirable character. His sincerity and willingness to learn from his mistakes made him a compelling romantic figure.

Atticus Finch from “To Kill a Mockingbird” by Harper Lee

woman smiling while reading
Image Credit_ DepositPhotos AntonLozovoy

The principled lawyer and devoted father, Atticus Finch embodies moral integrity and compassion. His unwavering pursuit of justice in the face of racism and prejudice is both admirable and deeply moving, making him a character that resonates with readers seeking inspiration in their own lives. Atticus’s steadfast belief in doing what is right, even when it’s difficult, has left an indelible mark on the hearts of many.

Heathcliff from “Wuthering Heights” by Emily Brontë

woman reading a book
Image Credit_ Depositphotos SIphotography

Heathcliff’s brooding intensity and tumultuous love for Catherine Earnshaw made him a complex and unforgettable character. His dark, passionate nature and the destructive force of his emotions left a lasting impression on readers.

Augustus Waters from “The Fault in Our Stars” by John Green

young girl reading
Image Credit_ Depositphotos puhimec

With his wit, wisdom, and vulnerability, Augustus Waters captured readers’ hearts as he navigated the complexities of life and love with Hazel Grace Lancaster. His courage and unwavering support for Hazel made him a cherished fictional crush.

15 Banned Picture Books You Might Remember From Your Childhood

Grandmother reading to a child
Image Credit Depositphotos NewAfrica

15 Banned Picture Books You Might Remember From Your Childhood – Children’s books are meant to entertain, educate, and inspire young minds. However, some have faced bans and controversies due…

Was Dr. Seuss Racist? 7 Dr. Seuss Books That Clearly Display Racism

Dr. Seuss Characters and an African American woman crying
Image Credit ShutterstockRon Ellis Woman crying ShotPrime Studio (1)

Was Dr. Seuss Racist? 7 Dr. Seuss Books That Clearly Display Racism – Dr. Seuss is known and beloved for his whimsical stories and colorful characters. However, some of his works have…

The Most Addictive Book Series: 15 Series That Will Make You Forget About Everything Else In Life

a woman reading a great book, looking happy and excited as she reads
Image Credit Depositphotos Krakenimages.com

The Most Addictive Book Series: 15 Series That Will Make You Forget About Everything Else In Life We all know that feeling of getting lost in a book series, unable to put it down until we’ve devoured…

Boomer Battle: 15 Books Boomers Love And Younger Generations Hate

woman reading a book looking confused
Image credits Depositphotos nicoletaionescu

Boomer Battle: 15 Books Boomers Love And Younger Generations Hate – Every generation has its own taste in literature, and what resonates with one may not strike a chord with…

15 Books You Have To Read Before You Die

woman with a book on her head looking happy and surprised .
Image credits Depositphotos Vadymvdrobot

15 Books You Have To Read Before You Die – Embarking on a literary journey is like traversing time, emotions, and cultures without ever leaving your seat. For book…

Motherhood Life Balance, Bookworm Era | + posts

Victoria Cornell helps women adopt a positive mindset even when the struggles of motherhood feel overwhelming. On her sites, Motherhood Life Balance, Neon Moon and Bookworm Era she writes about ways to reduce stress with mindset, manifesting, goal planning, productivity, and more.